Dilemmaskinen (The Dilemmachine)
Dilemmaskinen is a study, a digital game and a conversation starter, which focuses on welfare technologies and involves users in choosing how we, as a society, are to deal with future care tasks.
Dilemmaskinen has the form of a digital game, where the player is asked a series of questions and given tasks relating to welfare technology in their local care sector.
The objective of Dilemmaskinen is to generate debate and provoke users by showing them the worst possible consequences of their choices. The game consists of five questions and five tasks that are connected to the replies given. In the questionnaire, you can choose to give careful, balanced responses, but when you then come to performing the task related to the question, the real dilemma is introduced. In other words, there are no wrong or right answers in Dilemmaskinen. And there are no easy answers either
Dilemmaskinen has proven to be an excellent conversation starter. Many people who have tried Dilemmaskinen find it both thought-provoking and entertaining – and excellent for generating debate.
On the technical side, Dilemmaskinen has been designed to be extremely flexible. All texts and images are easily replaced. Dilemmaskinen can thus be programmed to deal with an entirely different subject, in which you wish to involve users and get input from.
In November 2012, the Danish Technological Institute (DTI) published an evaluation of a feeding robot. This generated heated public debate about whether welfare technology can be linked to better service and improved quality of life for citizens. The debate inspired Design School Kolding's Laboratory for Social Inclusion to develop a research design – Dilemmaskinen – which both encourages interested participants to take a stance on important welfare technology issues and also encourages them to reflect on the consequences of their choices.
Tested on users
Dilemmaskinen has been tested in several different environments: Among shoppers at Kolding Storcenter, among passengers at Odense Central Station, at DGI Huset in Aarhus, at Kolding Library and at a special workshop with the welfare technology partnership UNIK.